Quantum Biology: Real Effects, Open Questions and Hype

Home / Quantum / Quantum biology

Quantum approaches · Evidence review

Quantum Biology: Real Effects, Open Questions and Hype

Can quantum physics do useful work inside warm, wet living cells? For a few processes the answer is yes. For others it is a live debate, and for many popular claims it is no. Here is how to tell them apart.

CFBy The Conscious Field Editors · Updated November 14, 2026
European robin perched on a branch against a blurred green background
Key points
  • All chemistry is quantum at bottom; quantum biology asks where specifically quantum effects (tunnelling, coherence, entanglement) shape a biological function.
  • Electron and hydrogen tunnelling in enzymes are well established; the radical-pair compass in migratory birds is the strongest case for something more exotic, but is not fully proven in living animals.
  • None of these findings shows that consciousness is quantum, and none supports “quantum healing” products.

What quantum biology is, and what it is not

In a trivial sense every living thing is quantum: chemical bonds, the colours of pigments and the shape of proteins can only be explained with quantum mechanics. Nobody calls that quantum biology. The field is about something narrower: cases where a non-trivial quantum effect, such as a particle tunnelling through an energy barrier, a superposition that stays coherent for a useful time, or a pair of entangled electron spins, makes a measurable difference to how an organism works.

For most of the twentieth century this seemed unlikely. Quantum states are fragile, and the interior of a cell is hot, crowded and noisy, exactly the conditions that cause decoherence. The same argument is the central objection to quantum theories of mind such as Orch OR. Since the 2000s, however, better instruments have shown that biology sometimes finds ways to use quantum effects before the environment washes them out. The review by Lambert and colleagues in Nature Physics (2013) is a good map of the territory; a 2020 reassessment in Science Advances by Cao and colleagues is more sceptical about several early claims.

Tunnelling in enzymes and respiration

Established Tunnelling is the quantum ability of a particle to cross an energy barrier it could not climb classically. Electrons do this routinely in biology: in the respiratory chain of mitochondria and in photosynthetic reaction centres, electrons hop between metal centres and cofactors separated by more than a nanometre of protein. The rates match quantum theories of electron transfer developed by Rudolph Marcus and refined by Harry Gray, Jay Winkler and others, and this is textbook biochemistry.

Heavier particles tunnel too. In many enzymes that move a hydrogen atom, proton or hydride, replacing hydrogen by deuterium slows the reaction far more than classical chemistry predicts, and the temperature dependence of that “kinetic isotope effect” points to tunnelling. Work by Judith Klinman, Nigel Scrutton and colleagues has made hydrogen tunnelling an accepted part of enzymology. Debated What remains contested is whether protein motions have been selected to promote tunnelling, or whether tunnelling is simply what happens once atoms are held close together.

Photosynthesis: the coherence story and its correction

In 2007 Gregory Engel, Graham Fleming and colleagues reported in Nature that energy moving through a light-harvesting protein of green sulfur bacteria (the FMO complex) showed long-lived oscillations, or “quantum beats”, at 77 kelvin. They suggested that the excitation explores several pathways at once in a coherent superposition, a kind of quantum search that might explain the near-perfect efficiency of energy transfer. Follow-up work reported similar signals closer to room temperature, and the result became the flagship of quantum biology.

Macro view of a green leaf showing its network of veins

Debated A decade later the picture changed. Re-analyses and new experiments, notably by Duan and colleagues (PNAS, 2017), found that the electronic coherence in FMO under physiological conditions dies out within roughly 60 femtoseconds, too fast to steer energy transfer, and that the long-lived beats were mostly vibrational or mixed vibrational-electronic. Today most researchers agree that quantum effects shape energy transfer in light-harvesting complexes, since the energy is shared across molecules in a quantum way, but the idea of a long-lived “quantum search” improving efficiency is no longer the mainstream view. This is a good example of science correcting an exciting early claim.

The robin’s compass: the radical-pair mechanism

Migratory songbirds such as the European robin can sense the direction of Earth’s magnetic field, which is about a hundred times too weak to affect ordinary chemistry. In 1978 Klaus Schulten proposed a quantum explanation: light creates a radical pair, two molecules each carrying an unpaired electron, whose spins are entangled. The weak magnetic field changes how fast the pair flips between spin states, which changes the yield of a chemical product, and that could be read by the nervous system as a directional signal.

Debated The evidence has grown steadily. Ritz and colleagues (Nature, 2004) found that weak radio-frequency fields, which should disturb radical pairs but not a magnetic mineral, disoriented robins. Engels and colleagues (Nature, 2014) showed that low-level electromagnetic noise in an urban university campus disrupted robins’ orientation, which returned when the huts were shielded. In 2021 Xu and colleagues reported in Nature that cryptochrome 4 from the European robin, a protein in the retina, forms magnetically sensitive radical pairs in the laboratory. Hore and Mouritsen’s 2016 review calls the mechanism the leading hypothesis. What is still missing is a direct demonstration of the whole chain, from radical pair to neural signal, in a living bird, and some birds also seem to use iron-based magnetic sensing.

The “quantum nose”

Speculative In 1996 the biophysicist Luca Turin proposed that olfactory receptors detect molecular vibrations via inelastic electron tunnelling, not just molecular shape. It would explain why some molecules with different shapes smell alike. Experiments have been mixed: Keller and Vosshall (Nature Neuroscience, 2004) found that people could not tell a common odorant from its deuterated version, which the theory predicts should smell different, while Franco and colleagues (PNAS, 2011) reported that fruit flies could. Most olfaction researchers remain unconvinced, and shape-based binding explains the bulk of the data.

And the brain?

Quantum biology is often cited as evidence that the brain could be a quantum device. The honest summary is narrower. The cases above show that the “too warm and wet” objection is not absolute: tunnelling clearly works in proteins, and spin states can probably stay coherent for microseconds in a specialised protein. But each working example is a tiny, highly specific molecular process, not a large coherent state spread across neurons. The leading quantum models of mind, such as Orch OR or Matthew Fisher’s 2015 proposal that nuclear spins in phosphate clusters (“Posner molecules”) could store quantum information, remain Speculative. Recent laboratory reports of collective light effects in tubulin, discussed in microtubules and consciousness, are interesting but far from a demonstration that experience depends on them. For the broader picture, see is consciousness quantum? and the deeper puzzle of the hard problem.

A related but separate claim is that observation by a conscious mind is what makes quantum states definite. That is a question about the interpretation of physics, not about biology, and we examine it in does consciousness cause collapse?

Evidence Meter

ClaimGrade
Electron tunnelling drives respiration and photosynthetic charge transferEstablished
Hydrogen tunnelling contributes to many enzyme reactionsEstablished
Enzymes evolved motions to enhance tunnellingDebated
Long-lived electronic coherence makes photosynthesis more efficientDebated
Birds sense magnetic direction through radical pairs in cryptochromeDebated
Smell works by detecting molecular vibrationsSpeculative
Quantum coherence in the brain produces consciousnessSpeculative

How to read quantum biology headlines: ask which specific effect is meant (tunnelling, coherence or entanglement), whether it was measured in a living organism or a purified protein, at what temperature, and for how long it lasted. Products sold as “quantum” healing devices, supplements or energy therapies have no support from this research.

FAQ

Is quantum biology a real science?

Yes. It is a recognised interdisciplinary field with papers in journals such as Nature, PNAS and Nature Physics, and research groups in physics, chemistry and biology departments. Its findings range from textbook-level (electron tunnelling) to openly contested.

Does quantum biology prove that consciousness is quantum?

No. It shows that some molecules can exploit quantum effects for short times. Whether anything similar happens at the scale of neural networks, and whether it would explain experience, is a separate and unresolved question.

Why does decoherence not destroy every quantum effect in cells?

Tunnelling does not need long-lived coherence; it happens over tiny distances in very short times. Electron spins in radical pairs interact weakly with their surroundings, so they can stay coherent much longer than, say, the position of a whole molecule.

Are there medical applications?

Understanding tunnelling helps in drug and enzyme design, but quantum biology does not offer any treatment today. Health decisions should be made with a qualified professional, not on the basis of “quantum” marketing.

Sources

  1. Lambert, N. et al. (2013). Quantum biology. Nature Physics, 9.
  2. Cao, J. et al. (2020). Quantum biology revisited. Science Advances, 6(14).
  3. McFadden, J. & Al-Khalili, J. (2018). The origins of quantum biology. Proceedings of the Royal Society A, 474.
  4. Klinman, J. & Kohen, A. (2013). Hydrogen tunneling links protein dynamics to enzyme catalysis. Annual Review of Biochemistry, 82.
  5. Engel, G. et al. (2007). Evidence for wavelike energy transfer through quantum coherence in photosynthetic systems. Nature, 446.
  6. Duan, H.-G. et al. (2017). Nature does not rely on long-lived electronic quantum coherence for photosynthetic energy transfer. PNAS, 114(32).
  7. Ritz, T. et al. (2004). Resonance effects indicate a radical-pair mechanism for avian magnetic compass. Nature, 429.
  8. Engels, S. et al. (2014). Anthropogenic electromagnetic noise disrupts magnetic compass orientation in a migratory bird. Nature, 509.
  9. Xu, J. et al. (2021). Magnetic sensitivity of cryptochrome 4 from a migratory songbird. Nature, 594.
  10. Hore, P. & Mouritsen, H. (2016). The radical-pair mechanism of magnetoreception. Annual Review of Biophysics, 45.
  11. Keller, A. & Vosshall, L. (2004). A psychophysical test of the vibration theory of olfaction. Nature Neuroscience, 7.
  12. Fisher, M. (2015). Quantum cognition: the possibility of processing with nuclear spins in the brain. Annals of Physics, 362.